CITY COMPARISON

Hollister vs San Juan Bautista

Comparing Hollister and San Juan Bautista for home buyers: prices, schools, commute and the kinds of homes you will find.

Hollister vs San Juan Bautista at a glance

HollisterSan Juan Bautista
CountySan Benito CountySan Benito County
Population (2020 census)41,6782,089
Median sale price (3 months to Oct 2026)$723K$590K
Change vs a year earlier0.0%-27.2%
Median days on market36104
Homes sold in October 2026623
County median, single-family (Oct 2026)$743,000$743,000
School districtsHollister School District, San Benito HighAromas-San Juan Unified
Rail and transitCounty Express bus to Gilroy CaltrainCounty Express bus; Caltrain in Gilroy
Major roadsHwy 25, Hwy 156Hwy 156, US-101
NeighborhoodsDowntown Hollister, Sunnyslope, Ladd Lane, Cerra Vista, Santana Ranch, Rural HollisterHistoric District, Third Street, Mission Farm area, San Juan Valley

Home prices

Hollister had a median sale price of $723K over the three months ending October 2026 (0.0% from a year earlier). San Juan Bautista had a median sale price of $590K over the three months ending October 2026 (-27.2% from a year earlier). These Redfin figures cover all home types, so a place with more condos can show a lower median than one with mostly houses.

Both are in San Benito County, where the median single-family home sold for $743,000 in October 2026, according to the California Association of Realtors.

Side by side

Hollister

Hollister

Hollister is the county seat and largest city in San Benito County, about 15 miles southeast of Gilroy. It has a historic downtown along San Benito Street, established neighborhoods, newer subdivisions on the south and east sides, and ranches and orchards around the city.

Homes: You'll find early-1900s bungalows and Victorians near downtown, single-family subdivisions from the 1980s through today, newer homes in master-planned neighborhoods, and rural properties with acreage, wells and septic systems.

Getting around: Hwy 25 runs north to US-101 near Gilroy and south toward Pinnacles National Park. Hwy 156 heads west to San Juan Bautista and US-101, and east toward Hwy 152 and Pacheco Pass. San Benito County Express runs local buses and a route to the Gilroy Caltrain station. Hollister Hills State Vehicular Recreation Area is south of town.

Full Hollister guide →

San Juan Bautista

San Juan Bautista

San Juan Bautista is a small city in San Benito County, about 8 miles west of Hollister and 3 miles east of US-101. It grew up around Mission San Juan Bautista, founded in 1797, and its Third Street historic district still has buildings from the 1800s.

Homes: Homes include 19th-century adobes and Victorians near downtown, mid-century and ranch-style houses on nearby streets, newer single-family subdivisions, and country properties with acreage outside the city limits.

Getting around: Hwy 156 passes the edge of town, connecting west to US-101 and east to Hollister. Gilroy is about 20 minutes north on US-101. Fremont Peak State Park is 11 miles south, and the mission, state historic park and El Teatro Campesino are in town.

Full San Juan Bautista guide →

How to choose

Most buyers decide between Hollister and San Juan Bautista on commute, the style and size of home they want, and the school district that serves the specific address. Visit both at the times you would actually be there, and confirm school assignments with the district for any home you are considering. We are glad to set up tours in both.

Hollister guide · San Juan Bautista guide · More comparisons

Frequently asked questions

Is Hollister or San Juan Bautista better for buying a home?

It depends on your commute, budget and the type of home you want. This page compares county prices, school districts, transit and home styles in Hollister and San Juan Bautista; we can share recent sales in each.

What school districts serve Hollister and San Juan Bautista?

Hollister: Hollister School District, San Benito High. San Juan Bautista: Aromas-San Juan Unified. Always confirm the assigned school for a specific address with the district.

Questions about buying or selling in the Bay Area?

Talk with Joe Prather and the Who's Next Real Estate team, or call (831) 515-8133.

Sources

  1. Redfin, Hollister housing market (three months ending October 2026)
  2. Redfin, San Juan Bautista housing market (three months ending October 2026)
  3. California Association of Realtors, October 2026 Home Sales and Price Report

Updated November 17, 2026. General information, not legal, tax or lending advice. Who's Next Real Estate · eXp Realty of California, Inc. · CA DRE #01878277.